The Christian Brothers congregation has said it is committed to resolving historical abuse claims in a timely manner, as 314 former members were named in a newspaper advertisement connected to civil proceedings in Ireland.
The latest development, reported by RTÉ News on 17 November 2026, follows a similar publication in August 2026 involving 341 former members.
The men named in the advertisements are not accused of any wrongdoing. They have been joined to the proceedings because of the legal structure of the congregation and the difficulties involved in bringing claims against an unincorporated religious order.
For survivors considering Christian Brothers abuse claims, these developments raise important questions about the legal process, potential delays and whether claims can be resolved through mediation.
Coleman Legal LLP represents survivors of historical institutional abuse, including claims connected to the Christian Brothers.
Christian Brothers’ statement on abuse claims and mediation
In a statement reported by RTÉ in August 2026, Brother David Gibson, head of the Christian Brothers congregation in Ireland, said the congregation preferred to resolve claims through mediation rather than prolonged court proceedings.
The congregation said it had paid more than €40 million, including legal costs, in compensation to over 200 claimants.
Brother Gibson said that most claims notified to the congregation were settled within 12 months and maintained that lengthy litigation reduced the resources available to resolve future claims.
The congregation also referred to its contributions towards redress and statutory funds, as well as counselling provided to survivors.
However, the congregation’s approach to defending civil proceedings has attracted criticism, particularly where survivors have been required to join large numbers of former members to their cases.
Why were 314 former Christian Brothers named in a newspaper?
The latest newspaper advertisement relates to a claim for damages arising from alleged childhood sexual and physical abuse at a Christian Brothers primary school on Stephen Street in Kilkenny during the 1970s.
The claim concerns abuse by Liam Coughlan, a former Christian Brother who was imprisoned in 2023 for sexually assaulting boys.
Following the congregation’s decision not to nominate a representative to defend the proceedings, the High Court permitted the plaintiff to serve notice on 314 former members through a national newspaper advertisement.
Importantly, the former members named in the advertisement are not accused of committing or participating in the abuse.
They have been joined to the proceedings because of the legal arrangements governing claims against the congregation.
This is the second such publication in recent months.
In July 2026, Ms Justice Mary Rose Gearty authorised a similar approach involving 341 former members. Their names were subsequently published in August.
Political reaction to the Christian Brothers proceedings
The handling of these proceedings has attracted criticism from senior Government figures.
Speaking on 17 November 2026, Taoiseach Micheál Martin called on the Christian Brothers to face up to their responsibilities and deal properly with survivors, expressing concern about the length of time some survivors were spending in court.
Tánaiste Simon Harris also criticised the congregation’s approach to nominating a representative for civil proceedings.
The criticism centres on the additional procedural steps that survivors may face when attempting to pursue compensation claims against the congregation.
For its part, the Christian Brothers has maintained that its preferred approach is to resolve claims through mediation and settlement without unnecessary litigation.
The legal framework for Christian Brothers abuse claims in Ireland
A central issue in these proceedings is the legal status of the Christian Brothers congregation.
The congregation operates as an unincorporated association. Under Irish law, an unincorporated association generally has no separate legal personality and cannot ordinarily be sued in its own name.
This can require proceedings to be brought against individual members or an appropriate representative acting on behalf of the association.
Where no representative is nominated, a plaintiff may have to take additional procedural steps to identify and serve relevant members.
In certain circumstances, the High Court may permit service through a newspaper advertisement.
This explains why hundreds of former Christian Brothers have been named in recent proceedings, despite there being no allegation that those individuals personally committed abuse.
Can a religious order be held liable for historical abuse?
The potential liability of religious orders for abuse committed by their members was considered by the Supreme Court in Hickey v McGowan [2017] IESC 6.
The Court upheld the finding that members of the Marist Order could be held vicariously liable for sexual abuse committed by one of the order’s members in the circumstances of that case.
The decision is relevant to institutional abuse claims involving religious orders, although liability in each case depends on the particular facts and legal relationships involved.
What are the time limits for historical abuse claims?
Time limits for childhood sexual abuse claims in Ireland are governed by the Statute of Limitations Act 1957, as amended.
Section 48A, introduced by the Statute of Limitations (Amendment) Act 2000, provides special rules where psychological injury arising from childhood sexual abuse substantially impairs a person’s ability to bring proceedings.
These provisions recognise that survivors may experience psychological barriers that prevent them from pursuing legal action for many years.
However, the provisions do not automatically remove time limits in every case.
The circumstances of each claim must be considered individually, and survivors should seek independent legal advice about the applicable limitation period.
What do these developments mean for survivors?
For survivors of childhood abuse in Christian Brothers institutions, the current proceedings highlight the importance of understanding the legal process and the options available for resolving a claim.
The congregation has publicly stated that it prefers mediation, which allows parties to explore settlement without proceeding to a contested court hearing.
However, mediation does not guarantee that an agreement will be reached.
Where a claim cannot be resolved through negotiation or mediation, court proceedings may be necessary.
The procedural difficulties associated with identifying and serving members of an unincorporated religious order can also affect how a claim progresses.
Anyone considering a Christian Brothers abuse claim should obtain independent legal advice about their individual circumstances, the relevant time limits and any proposed settlement.
The fact that former members have been named in newspaper advertisements does not mean they have been accused of abuse.
How Coleman Legal LLP can help
Coleman Legal LLP represents survivors of historical institutional and clerical abuse, including proceedings connected to the Christian Brothers.
Philip Treacy, Solicitor, has spoken publicly about these proceedings, including on RTÉ’s News at One.
He has explained that the publication of former members’ names arises from the congregation’s decision not to nominate a representative to defend the proceedings.
Patrick Coleman also advises clients on historical abuse claims.
Our solicitors assist survivors in understanding their legal options, gathering relevant evidence and navigating the claims process.
If you experienced abuse in a Christian Brothers institution and would like to understand your legal position, our team can provide confidential advice.




