Dianne Willmore, who passed from mesothelioma in 2009, won a landmark £240,000 case, holding Knowsley Borough Council liable for her asbestos exposure during school. Her case prompted legal and financial ramifications for local authorities nationwide, leading to increased awareness and changes in asbestos-related negligence proceedings.
Shane Flynn, 35, owner of a Mullingar clinic, was convicted of sexual assault after inappropriately touching a client seeking back pain relief. The investigation also revealed 18 hours of footage showing Flynn secretly filming 35 women during massages, raising further concerns about his conduct and abuse of trust within his practice.
Naveed Rana, a Dublin taxi driver, was sentenced to five and a half years for the assault of an 18-year-old woman after a night out. The court heard how Rana took advantage of the victim’s trust, driving erratically and assaulting her before being apprehended due to her quick actions in reporting the incident to Gardaí.
Defective Blocks newsletter and latest updates.
Mother and Baby Homes redress newsletter and latest updates.
CAMHS newsletter and latest updates.
If you have valuable insights or experiences related to the Defence Forces Tribunal, now is the time to ensure your voice is part of the inquiry. Coleman Legal LLP is here to assist Defence Forces personnel in preparing detailed submissions for this crucial investigation into complaints processes, systemic issues, and accountability. For guidance, reach out to us at 1800-844-104 or [email protected]
In July 2023, the Government approved the establishment of a Tribunal of Inquiry to investigate the effectiveness of the complaints processes within the Defence Forces, following a series of revelations surrounding allegations of discrimination, harassment, and misconduct. This Tribunal was established under the Tribunals of Inquiry (Evidence) Acts 1921 to 2011, with its Terms of Reference ratified by the Dáil and Seanad in January 2024.
The Defence Forces Tribunal, chaired by a Sole Member: Ms. Justice Ann Power, has been tasked with conducting an inquiry into complaints of abuse and the systemic failings of the complaints processes currently in existence within the Defence Forces. The Tribunal’s mandate stems from recommendations made by the Independent Review Group (IRG), which was established to examine workplace issues relating to harassment and discrimination within the Defence Forces. The IRG’s report, published in March 2023, (available here) called for a formal inquiry into the handling of such complaints. The Tribunal’s first public sitting was held on 24 June 2024, marking the beginning of an extensive investigation into the complaints processes and culture within the Defence Forces. More information on the Tribunal can be accessed here.
The Tribunal is examining a broad range of issues as outlined in its Terms of Reference, including:
These issues are being scrutinised to assess whether the current and historic systems are fit for purpose and whether changes need to be made to protect personnel and ensure accountability.
The Tribunal has extended the deadline to make submissions to the 16 December 2024. This means that it is imperative that we get any submissions in before close of business on that date. The Tribunal has called for individuals who possess knowledge, information, or material relevant to its Terms of Reference to come forward and provide comprehensive statements.
These submissions are crucial, as they will aid the Tribunal in building a clear understanding of how complaints were handled within the Defence Forces, particularly regarding allegations of abuse, systemic failings, and retaliation against complainants. Statements received during the Tribunal’s investigative stage have been treated as confidential, though public hearings may follow where necessary, subject to the Tribunal’s discretion.
The Tribunal has ruled on applications for representation made by various representative bodies, including the Defence Forces, the Minister for Defence, and several interest groups such as PDFORRA, Women of Honour, Lariam Justice Group and the Air Corps Chemical Abuse Survivors. While limited representation was granted to many of these groups during the investigative stage, decisions regarding representation at the public hearings stage have been deferred.
The Tribunal has emphasised that should further public hearings be necessary, parties granted limited representation during the investigative stage will have an opportunity to apply for full representation during the hearings. What is also clear is that individuals who fit the terms of reference and who are allowed to submit will also be allowed to apply for legal representation at an appropriate time.
The deadline for submissions to the Defence Forces Tribunal has been extended until 16 December 2024. At Coleman Legal LLP, we understand the importance of having your voice heard, and we are here to assist you in making a comprehensive and detailed submission.
If you are a serving or former member of the Defence Forces, or if you believe you have relevant information related to the issues under investigation, we encourage you to reach out. Our team is prepared to provide you with the legal guidance and support needed to ensure your experiences are effectively presented within the extended timeline.
If you have knowledge or information relevant to the Defence Forces Tribunal, we invite you to consider taking the following steps:
Gather any evidence or documentation related to your experience within the Defence Forces. Ensure your statement is as detailed as possible, considering the Tribunal’s focus on complaints processes, retaliation, and systemic failures.
Working with experienced solicitors can help ensure that your statement addresses the necessary aspects of the Tribunal and aligns with the Tribunal’s Terms of Reference. Register your details below, and we will have one of our Defence Forces Tribunal Team contact you to assist.
Our Defence Forces Tribunal team consists of two veterans, Norman Spicer and Steven Whelan. They will be assisted by legal executive Kayleigh Moran and, at times, by Legal Director Susan Hannon.
Norman Spicer is a veteran non-commissioned former Defence Forces member, having served for 9 years (over the course of a 12-year period with a career break in between) overseas in Chad in 2009. Norman has been practising as a lawyer since 2013 (in both New York and Ireland), with significant experience in defence litigation, personal injury suits, and multi-party litigation.
Steven Whelan is a veteran non-commissioned former member of the Defence Forces who served for over 10 years, including overseas service in Chad and Lebanon. Steven has been a lawyer since 2015 (in New York and Ireland) and has significant experience in defence litigation, public and regulatory law, and data protection.
The Defence Forces Tribunal represents a significant step in addressing historical and ongoing issues within the Irish Defence Forces. While the initial window for submissions has closed, there remains a good possibility for further statements to be accepted. If you have experienced discrimination, harassment, or abuse within the Defence Forces or know relevant to the Tribunal’s inquiries, now is the time to prepare.
We at Coleman Legal LLP are here to guide and support you through the process. Contact us today to discuss your potential submission, and let us help ensure that your voice is heard if and when the Tribunal re-opens the call for statements.
Solicitors
84 Talbot Street, Dublin 1
D01 YX60
Free Phone: (1800)844104
Fax: (01) 5312727
Email: [email protected]
Web: www.colemanlegalpartners.ie
