Category: Medical Negligence

Halpin Report into North Kerry CAMHS released

The Halpin Report, published in February 2026, examines the care of 374 children in North Kerry CAMHS, identifying risks of harm, over-prescribing, governance failures and a series of clinical and operational reforms.

Temple Street Spinal Surgery Review: What Families Need to Know About the Clinical Recall

The Temple Street spinal surgery review has led to 62 children being recalled for clinical reassessment following concerns about orthopaedic surgical outcomes. This guide explains what the review involves, what families can expect from the HSE process, and the legal considerations parents should be aware of if they have concerns about their child’s treatment.

T.D. Pa Dalys call for urgent assistance in essential Mental Health services in Kerry, and publication of the Halpin report, with any further delay

Pa Daly TD has renewed calls for urgent investment in mental health services in Kerry, highlighting dangerous assessment delays for young people in crisis and the continued non-publication of the Halpin report into North Kerry CAMHS, which remains outstanding despite confirmation that it was completed in 2025.

Solicitor Keith Rolls criticises the continued delay in publishing the Halpin Report, as families still await answers about the care provided to children by North Kerry CAMHS.

As of January 2026, the Halpin Report into North Kerry CAMHS remains unpublished, despite the completion of all individual clinical file reviews.

The delay in publishing the report on the Lookback Review in North Kerry CAMHS is distressing for the affected families.

The North Kerry CAMHS Review examined 300 patient files, but its unpublished report continues to cause distress for affected families.

Sodium Valproate Inquiry [2025]

The Sodium Valproate Inquiry in Ireland commenced on 22 July 2025, marking a major investigation into the drug’s historic use and its devastating impact on children exposed in the womb.

CHI apologises to families amid concerns over the CHI hip surgery review

The CHI hip surgery review has uncovered serious issues in paediatric care, prompting an apology from CHI and a commitment to reform.

VHI launches investigation into unnecessary hip surgeries that were the subject of health insurance claims

VHI has begun investigating claims for unnecessary hip surgeries at Temple Street and Cappagh hospitals. This follows a report detailing procedures that didn’t meet clinical thresholds, prompting the insurer to review its reimbursement protocols and the medical necessity of these operations.

Report uncovers “very serious concerns” over unnecessary hip surgeries in Dublin children’s hospitals [2025]

A recent audit has uncovered alarming concerns over unnecessary hip surgery in Dublin children’s hospitals, with hundreds of cases flagged for urgent review and follow-up.

Death of baby at Portiuncala University hospital leads to new review

Portiuncula Hospital faces intensified scrutiny as a tenth external review into its maternity services begins, following a recent baby’s death.

Assessment of Needs for Children- Minister Norma Foley admits that we need to do better

The HSE has failed to carry out thousands of assessments of needs within the statutory timeframe, affecting children’s access to support services.

Unborn Babies Wrongly Diagnosed with Fatal Foetal Abnormality before Termination

Two Irish families allege they were advised to terminate pregnancies after being misdiagnosed with fatal foetal abnormality later discovering their babies were healthy.

Failings at in maternity service cost the State 320m between 2015 and 2019

A review by the State Claims Agency of maternity claims from 2015-2019 has revealed critical failures in fetal heart monitoring, CTG trace interpretation, and labour induction methods. Advocacy groups, including Safer Births Ireland, have called for an in-depth inquiry as concerns over maternity care persist,

External Review to begin at Portiuncula Hospital in light of concerns regarding the delivery of nine babies

Maternity services at Portiuncula Hospital are under external review after a concerning number of neonatal complications, including cases of hypoxic ischaemic encephalopathy (HIE) and stillbirths. The HSE has appointed an external management team to oversee improvements and ensure patient safety.

Young father dies following nine hour wait and misdiagnosis at Cork University Hospital

Pat Murphy, a 34-year-old father, died after a ruptured artery went undiagnosed at Cork University Hospital. Despite suffering severe chest pains, he faced a nine-hour wait for a CT scan, delayed further by a malfunctioning machine. His family claims this delay contributed to his tragic death.

The initial stage of the review in CAMHS in North Kerry is set to take twice as long as the HSE initially anticipated

The CAMHS in North Kerry review, expected to finish by early 2024, has now been delayed until 2025, causing frustration among families. Only 300 cases are being examined, leaving many without answers as delays mount. Families and advocates are calling for an expanded review and quicker resolution to the alleged harm caused by the service.

Woman dies in Beaumont Hospital after being given eight times the correct dosage

Dublin woman, 92, dies at Beaumont Hospital after fatal blood pressure medication overdose. Hospital urged for systemic changes.

Dental Negligence Claims

If you’ve been affected by dental negligence, contact Coleman Legal LLP for experienced legal advice and support. Call us at 1800-844-104 or email [email protected] to discuss your legal options.

Mayo Hospital apologises for the death of patient (72) in High Court settlement

The Moyles family has reached a settlement with Mayo Hospital after Ann Moyles’ death in 2017. She was left on a trolley for 20 hours in the Emergency Department, leading to her demise.

Mother awarded over half a million pounds in damages following traumatic childbirth

Mother awarded £575,000 after childbirth injuries left her with a permanent stoma and PTSD. Maternity negligence claims highlight systemic issues in England’s healthcare

Mother of 11-year-old suicide victim settles legal battle

Fiona Tuomey, mother of 11-year-old Milly Tuomey, who tragically died by suicide, reaches a €65,000 settlement in her lawsuit, highlighting systemic failures in youth psychiatric care. If you’ve been affected, seek support.

Hundreds of complaints against single dentist highlights need for regulatory overhaul

Dentist Anne Hahessy from Oranmore, Co Galway, faces over 1,500 complaints. Despite this, regulatory gaps persist in ensuring patient safety and effective oversight in the dental profession.

Lack of learning and transparency to blame for rising hospital liabilities

Hospital liabilities in Ireland are projected to surpass 4 billion. Experts stress transparency and external investigations to reduce claims and improve patient trust.

Woman dies of internal bleeding after giving birth

Post-partum haemorrhage (PPH) remains a leading cause of maternal death worldwide. The recent tragic case at St Lukes Hospital, Kilkenny, highlights the risks and growing concerns about maternal healthcare in Ireland.

Childrens spinal surgery review delayed as new cases emerge at Temple Street Childrens Hospital

An independent review of spinal surgeries at Temple Street Children’s Hospital has been delayed due to 17 new “cases of concern,” doubling the number of procedures under scrutiny.

Galway University Hospital apologises after baby is born “head first” on to the floor

Galway University Hospital apologises for shortcomings in care that led to Baby Chelsie McDonagh’s death after she fell headfirst to the floor during delivery.

High Court awards nearly €100,000 for defective dental treatment

A Galway woman was awarded by Mr Justice Michael O’Higgins, who awarded the claimant €99,789 following her testimony, input from a dental specialist, and reports from multiple dental experts, €100,000 for defective dental treatment, experiencing severe pain and infections due to negligent work by dental practitioners in Ennis, Co Clare.

Report of Boston Childrens Hospital on Spinal Surgeries at CHI Temple Street

The CHI have today published the report of Boston Children’s Hospital on spinal surgeries carried out on young patients with Spina Bifida.

Childrens Health Ireland Report on Spinal Surgery for Patients with Spina Bifida at Temple Street

Childrens Health Ireland released a report on spinal surgeries for Spina Bifida patients at Temple Street Hospital, highlighting serious post-operative incidents and ongoing investigations into surgical outcomes from 2018 to 2022.

Minister for Health announces full national review of all children’s orthopaedic surgery

Minister for Health announces a comprehensive review of children’s orthopaedic surgery in Ireland, focusing on safety concerns and long waiting times, following Temple Street Children’s Hospital issues.

Taoiseach Leo Varadkar expresses serious concern on alleged failures at Temple Street Hospital

Taoiseach Leo Varadkar expresses deep concern over severe complications from spinal surgeries at Temple Street Children’s Hospital, prompting a comprehensive review by a UK expert into the incidents and use of unapproved devices.

External review launched by HSE into care of children with Spina Bifida at CHI Temple Street

Following a child’s death during spinal surgery at Temple Street Childrens Hospital, the HSE has initiated an external review of clinical care for Spina Bifida patients led by UK expert Mr Selvadurai Nayagam.

New data reveals dramatic regional disparities in access to Child and Adolescent Mental Health Care

Over half of the children and adolescents referred to their local CAMHS are being denied access in certain regions of the country.

External review into the delivery of babies who suffered Subgaleal Haemorrhages at birth in University Hospital Galway

A review of maternity deliveries at University Hospital Galway will investigate cases of subgaleal haemorrhage in newborns, focusing on difficult deliveries involving vacuum extractors. Coleman Legal LLP supports affected families who are seeking answers.

Over 3,000 fatalities caused by accidents within the HSE since 2018

New HSE data reveals 3,000 deaths from 480,000 incidents since 2018, highlighting falls, assaults, and medication issues. Calls for reforms and investment grow as incident numbers peak in the last year.

Non-Statutory Inquiry approved by Cabinet into Sodium Valproate use

Health Minister Stephen Donnelly announces a non-statutory inquiry into the historical prescription of sodium valproate during pregnancy, addressing severe developmental disorders and birth defects linked to the epilepsy drug Epilim.

Family of a woman who died of breast cancer received an apology from The National Screening Service

The National Screening Service, operating BreastCheck, apologised for missing abnormalities in Kay O’Keefe’s mammograms, which delayed her breast cancer diagnosis and treatment.

Lack of follow-up care in CAMHS as the Mental Health Commission’s report published

The Mental Health Commission published a report this weekend highlighting serious shortfalls in the care provided nationwide by the CAMHS.

A further 16 families receive apology from HSE after care of children found to be “Risky”

A Further 16 Families Receive Apology From HSE After Care Of Children Found To Be “Risky”

North Kerry CAMHS Audit

The HSE is set to release findings from the review of North Kerry CAMHS patient files, highlighting similar care deficits as those found in South Kerry.

€15m awarded after Failings in after birth care

An apology has been given to a teenage boy after the Coombe Women and Infants University Hospital failed to provide care to him after birth.

€300k Settlement After Failure to Detect Girls Hearing Loss

A settlement of €300,000 was approved today by the High Court in the case of a nine-year-old girl whose hearing loss was not detected for three years.

HSE reviewing the files of patients treated by a doctor in North Kerry CAMHS

HSE has commenced a review of the files of young patients treated by a junior doctor in North Kerry CAMHS. 

North Kerry CAMHS Misdiagnosis

Coleman Legal LLP continue to receive instructions from North Kerry families regarding the care their loved ones received while attending North Kerry CAMHS.

The court approves a €20,000 settlement in a case concerning the wrongful dispensing of sedatives to a 15-month-old child

The court approves a €20,000 settlement in a case concerning the wrongful dispensing of sedatives to a 15-month-old child.

CAMHS Kerry Compensation Scheme Latest News

Minister of state for mental health Mary Butler has confirmed the CAMHS Kerry Compensation Scheme for families affected by this scandal.

Compensation will be provided to the families harmed while under the care of CAMHS

Leo Varadkar has informed the Dáil that Compensation for CAMHS Misdiagnosis will be paid to the families of children, harmed under the care.

CAMHS Medication Misdiagnosis Controversy: Doctor Says He Would Make same Decisions Again

CAMHS Medication Misdiagnosis – Dr. David Kromer, Jr. doctor in the midst of controversy at CAMHS said he has no regrets about his decisions.

Child medication misdiagnosis controversy: mother of suicidal boy highly critical of health services

Child Medication Misdiagnosis – Mother of Suicidal Boy Highly Critical of Health Services at CAMHS Kerry attempted to take his own life.

HSE issues dozens of apologies after children prescribed “excessive medication”

The HSE apologises to children and their families following an assessment into the alleged over-prescription of medication at CAMHS Kerry,

Coleman Legal will represent families in Kerry who are suing the HSE for suspected misdiagnosis and over-medication of children at CAMHS Kerry.

Suspected misdiagnosis of some children in recent years by CAMHS Kerry has prompted families to issue legal proceedings against the HSE.

Girl settles birth injury case against Cork University Maternity Hospital for €375,000

High Court action brought on behalf of a girl whose shoulder was allegedly injured during her birth at Cork University Maternity Hospital has been settled for €375,000.

HSE sued for over-medication in CAMHS (Kerry)

HSE sued for over-medication. Coleman Legal has issued High Court medical negligence proceedings against the HSE on behalf of a minor boy.

Irish children suffering with scoliosis utilising spinal rod support systems to be audited after product recall

Irish scoliosis sufferers equipped with the “telescopic” Magec System Model X titanium support rods will be audited and may need to have the rods removed as a safety precaution. Scoliosis is a condition concerning the severe curvature of the spine, affecting nearly one percent of Irish adolescents. The treatment is determined by the intensity of […]

Vaginal mesh lawsuits lost by Johnson & Johnson

A landmark lawsuit has been won by 1,350 Australian women against Johnson & Johnson relating to vaginal mesh implants. According to Australia’s Federal Court, it appears that there had been a shortfall in the amount of  information  given to surgeons and patients about the risks of this procedure. The vaginal mesh product is usually utilized to treat females pelvic organs […]

Swine flu vaccine case settlement

Aoife Bennett a student from Naas, Co Kildare, has claimed that she had developed a sleeping disorder after having taken up a swine flu vaccination.  The details of the settlement have not been made public, however, she is to receive compensation due to the incident. The High court directed that the costs are to be paid by the Minister […]

High Court settlement due to delay in diagnosis of Hypokalaemia

HSE and GP issue apology to man who settles case for €850k for wife’s death A High Court action has been settled for €850k where a man sued a GP and the HSE following the death of his wife just one day after a blood test showed she had high levels of potassium in November […]

HSE Audiology Review

The Health Service Executive is to apologise to almost 50 families in the west of Ireland for serious failings in audiology services provided to their children. HSE Audiology Review This follows the completion of a review of past paediatric audiology services provided in more than 900 cases by one audiologist in Mayo and Roscommon, between […]

HSE admits significant failings by Portlaoise Hospital

[et_pb_section bb_built=”1″][et_pb_row][et_pb_column type=”4_4″][et_pb_text _builder_version=”3.2.2″ text_orientation=”justified” header_text_align=”left”] Significant failings in the care of a mother at Portlaoise Hospital   The HSE have admitted that there were significant failings in the care of a mother and her baby in November 2001 at Portlaoise hospital and have admitted that lessons have been learned and changes have been implemented […]

Breast Cancer Misdiagnosis

[et_pb_section fb_built=”1″ _builder_version=”3.0.47″][et_pb_row _builder_version=”3.0.48″ background_size=”initial” background_position=”top_left” background_repeat=”repeat”][et_pb_column type=”4_4″ _builder_version=”3.0.47″][et_pb_text _builder_version=”3.0.74″ background_size=”initial” background_position=”top_left” background_repeat=”repeat”] Breast Cancer Misdiagnosis in Ireland Two women to date have been affected by breast cancer misdiagnosis at St. James’s Hospital in Dublin, after a review of the pathologist’s work. Having been diagnosed with ductal carcinoma in situ (DCIS) in 2010, it has […]

Cervical Check Redress Scheme announced for women affected by Cervical Cancer Misdiagnosis

Cervical Check Redress Scheme announced for women affected by Cervical Cancer Misdiagnosis Calls for HSE to review all Cervical Cancer Misdiagnosis In light of the revelations of the last week, an Taoiseach Leo Varadkar has announced that a redress scheme for women affected by Cerical Cancer Misdiagnosis will be put in place. Mr Varadkar told […]

Cervical Cancer Misdiagnosis – Too Little, Too Late

[et_pb_section fb_built=”1″ _builder_version=”3.0.47″][et_pb_row _builder_version=”3.20.2″ background_size=”initial” background_position=”top_left” background_repeat=”repeat”][et_pb_column type=”4_4″ _builder_version=”3.0.47″][et_pb_text _builder_version=”3.20.2″ background_size=”initial” background_position=”top_left” background_repeat=”repeat”] Cervical Cancer Misdiagnosis – Too Little, Too Late It has taken Vicky Phelan’s successful High Court action against a US based clinical laboratory subcontracted by CervicalCheck, for CervicalCheck failures to come to light this week. On Wednesday, 25 April 2018 Vicky Phelan (43) […]

High Court action settled for €525,000 by woman after her husband died from prostate cancer

High Court action settled for €525,000 by woman after her husband died from prostate cancer A woman has settled a High Court Action for €525,000. She was suing over the care of her late husband who later passed away from prostate cancer. He was 56 years old when he died in January 2015.   His […]

HSE apology after undiagnosed heart defect results in death

  HSE apology after undiagnosed heart defect results in death of toddler (2) Following the tragic death of a two year old girl who died after a hole in the heart went undiagnosed, the Health Service Executive (HSE) has issued an unreserved apology. The child passed away as she was being transferred from University Hospital […]

Excessive Radiation Dose

Excessive Radiation Dose Radiation therapy is a common treatment for cancer.  Radiation works by making small breaks in the DNA inside cells, preventing cancer cells from growing and dividing. Unlike chemotherapy, radiation is usually a localised treatment. Some radiation treatments, systemic radiation therapy, are given intravenously or orally. Errors during the procedures of a radiation […]

University Hospital Kerry patients affected by review

University Hospital Kerry patients affected by review: Helpline opened this morning As of this morning, a helpline has opened for worried patients of University Hospital Kerry, who may be worried about scan results amid concerns about patient safety at the hospital. A review is being conducted of some 46,000 cat scans, x-rays, and ultrasounds following […]

Woman with DePuy hip replacement awarded €321k by High Court

DePuy Watch: High Court awards €321,000 in damages to 81 year old woman from Cork with DePuy hip replacement The case was fought all the way by DePuy and ran for no less than 20 days in Court Number 2 at the Four Courts. Joan Dineen from Co Cork was, according to Mr Justice Kevin Cross, […]

Hospital Waiting Lists issue for Scoliosis Patients in Ireland

Hospital Waiting Lists issue for Scoliosis Patients in Ireland Speaking on the ‘RTÉ Investigates’ programme, a woman discussed the suffering endured by both her family and her seven-year old son, who was diagnosed with infantile scoliosis, due to the delay in hospital waiting lists. The young boy was required to undergo spinal bracing and body […]

Misdiagnosis/Delayed Diagnosis of Hearing Loss in Children

[et_pb_section bb_built=”1″ fullwidth=”on” specialty=”off” next_background_color=”#000000″][et_pb_fullwidth_image _builder_version=”3.2.2″ src=”http://colemanlegalpartners.ie/staging-site/wp-content/uploads/2018/05/Hearing-Loss-Compensation-Header.jpg” /][/et_pb_section][et_pb_section bb_built=”1″ prev_background_color=”#000000″][et_pb_row][et_pb_column type=”4_4″][et_pb_button _builder_version=”3.2.2″ button_text=”READ MORE about Hearing Loss Misdiagnosis” button_url=”http://colemanlegalpartners.ie/staging-site/hearing-loss-compensation/” button_alignment=”center” custom_button=”on” button_text_color=”#ffffff” button_bg_use_color_gradient=”on” button_bg_color_gradient_start=”#01ffff” button_bg_color_gradient_end=”#4ec4b0″ box_shadow_style=”preset2″ /][et_pb_text _builder_version=”3.2.2″ text_orientation=”justified”] Misdiagnosis/Delayed Diagnosis of Hearing Loss in Children A child’s ability to hear is of paramount importance during their early years as they develop speech and language […]

Personal injury arising out of Lip Implant and Lip Filler Procedures

Personal injury arising out of Lip Implant and Lip Filler Procedures Both lip implant and lip filler procedures are usually carried out without complication, however where complications arise, the resulting consequences and symptoms of same can be most distressing. Lip Fillers Dermal fillers are used to enhance the lips and create a fuller, but natural […]